When a young foreigner is chased into his Paris church by white supremacists, Father Bernard sees a man he remembers from his youth in Nazi-Occupied France and thought long-dead.
In flashback to 1943 Paris, Immortal Ernst Daimler is a Nazi officer and Duncan is part of a Resistance group based at a monastery. While Duncan leads the Resistance group as they ambush a Nazi courier, little Bernard sees him shot, die, and revive, but Duncan binds Bernard to secrecy.
In modern day, Father Bernard realizes Daimler is also an Immortal and asks Duncan to help stop Daimler, who is now the leader of a white supremacist group working for a cause within the system.
Also, Anne tells Duncan that she is pregnant, but Duncan isn't sure if his lifestyle can allow for raising a child.