Lucy had been hurt by her immortal husband's reaction to his old friend Amanda, and may have been a bit jealous. Geary told her just the right things, she was deceived, and went with him to his apartment. Wilson took advantage of it for a perfidious plan: He called her husband, Marco Becker, claiming that Lucy was dead. In his rage Becker stormed into his home, and was stunned finding Lucy alive. Geary ambushed the surprised actor and took his head without a fight.
In 1998, Geary had a successful one man show called Methuselah's Revenge at the Music Hall of Chicago. He was soon booked for Denver. After a performance Lucy Becker tried to behead him. Afterward, Wilson located her address by posing as her public defender at the local police station.During his visit at Amanda's apartment, he met Nick Wolfe and Amanda. He told a very different version of the story of Marco's death, wherein he protected Lucy from an angry husband. The truth was, of course, somewhere in the middle.
Wilson finally kidnapped Lucy and tried to lure Amanda into a trap. He fought with Amanda at the Music Hall, and was beheaded.
- Geary's age is unknown but Amanda stated that Geary performed at the Globe Theatre, that has existed from 1599 to 1642.